I recently saw this 50th-anniversary production, which features great performances, lovely music and an especially detestable Scrooge. Director and choreographer Taavon Gamble is intimately familiar with the play, having choreographed three past Christmas Carols and performed in eight at Trinity Rep. He said that, with this year’s show, he wanted to focus on what it takes to open up a closed heart, “and dealing with the idea that redemption is a communal effort. You know, it takes everybody in the community to help change a person, and that it was really important to me to really focus on the plight of London's destitute. … And then I knew that I wanted to figure out a different way of framing the story, since it's such a story that everyone knows so well. And for me, it was about, okay, let's look at it sort of as a memory play through the eyes of an older version of Tiny Tim, looking back on this story. And once I kind of got there, the whole thing just kind of opened up for me.”
I enjoyed the winking energy John Shuman brought to the stage as both elder Tiny Tim and a fun, unusual take on the Ghost of Christmas Past. Mathieu Myrick was very charming as Bob Cratchit. Most of the actors played multiple characters, and I want to shout out one person who played a couple of smaller roles, including Mrs. Dilber, Scrooge’s housekeeper. Giselle – one name – didn’t have a ton of lines, but they delivered some funny moments that got everyone laughing, often thanks to their excellent facial expressions. One of the child actors, 11-year-old Gabriel Taveras, also had great comedic timing and ended up being quite the scene-stealer.
A weaker part of the play for me was Scrooge’s visit from the Ghost of Christmas Present. I enjoy the actor, Jackie Davis, who I’ve seen and loved in other productions at Trinity. So I was excited when she sauntered on stage in an incredible costume. But the Ghost of Christmas Present is such a critical moment in this story. Yes, Scrooge witnesses a number of distressing scenes of suffering around the world, and continues to reckon with his impact on others. But it’s also the point in the play where he finally learns, or re-learns, what joy is, what compassion is, and that he, too, yearns for it. It’s the inflection point for the character, where he is on the other side of his transformation from villainous scoundrel to generous, reformed man. But this had all the admonishing of Scrooge and too little of the joy. And that did undercut somewhat the emotional journey that is the center of this story.
Musically, I loved the original music by Richard Cumming, and I was pleasantly surprised to hear the cast belt out a personal favorite traditional song of the season, “The Malpas Wassail.”
Overall, it was a more dour version of the story than I’ve seen in other interpretations, including last year’s production at Trinity, which incorporated a nice amount of delight and magic along with the sadder moments, in a way that I found more emotionally resonant. This year felt heavier on the bitter, lighter on the sweet.
I asked director Taavon Gamble whether he thinks this tradition will continue for another 50 years. “I hope so,” he said. “You know, I think it's such a wonderful tradition, and you know that we're really one of very few, if the only theater in the country that recreates this every year. You know, a lot of theaters have a trunk show, and they just do the same thing every year, bring it in. But we start from a new script, from a new director, new design team, cast, entire design team, and do it new every year, which I think is refreshing, and I hope this is a tradition that continues.
The 50th-anniversary production of A Christmas Carol at Trinity Rep is on now through December 31.