What started as one Rhode Island assistant principal’s quest to eat his way through 40 pizzerias in 30 days has turned into something much bigger: local celebrity status, an unexpected friendship with a filmmaker and now a feature-length documentary.
But for Tim Chace, the pizza was never really the point.
Tim Chace’s desire to write wasn’t driven by fame or notoriety, but by a search for meaning.
“Three years ago, I became an empty-nester,” said Chace. “I had this big, existential crisis, which was essentially, ‘What do I like to do with my time?’ Sometimes, that’s a difficult thing to figure out.”
In college, Chace dreamed of becoming a professional writer, but decided to take the safer route and pursue a career in education instead. But recently, the assistant principal at Coventry High School decided to revisit that youthful dream, a decision that would turn him into a local celebrity.
Chace’s story is the subject of a new feature documentary called “The Pizza Principal.” The film follows Chace on his quest to catch a publisher's attention by writing a series of online pizza reviews.
Chace’s initial intention was to visit 40 pizzerias in 30 days. As he began publishing his written reviews on social media, he tried to focus primarily, as you would expect, on the pizza. But that changed after he posted a widely shared review of Merlino’s Pizzeria in Cranston, which featured a vivid description of Carmine, its lovable pizzamaker.
“Behind the counter, Carmine works with the quiet confidence of a guy who knows exactly what he's doing and why,” wrote Chace. “He's part artist, part scientist, part neighborhood character, the kind of person who turns a pizza shop into something more.”
Chase says the public response to that review was a pleasant surprise.
“People started showing up to that spot and asking to talk to the pizza man who works back there because I wrote about him instead of writing about the pizza, necessarily,” said Chace. “His humanity and warmth and desire to make people happy is what impressed me more than food. That changed the course of how I’m going to write.”
Eventually, one of Chace’s reviews caught Kirk Benttinen's attention. He’s a local filmmaker who recently returned to Rhode Island to pursue his film career after spending nearly a dozen years on the West Coast. Benttinen was relaxing at home one night in 2024 when his wife, Kendra, saw one of Tim Chace’s pizza reviews.
“She read this review, and I’m laughing, and I’m excited about the pizza,” said Benttinen. “By the end of it, my eyes are starting to water a little bit because I was really moved by Tim’s words.”
Rather than simply describing the food, Chace's review offered a glimpse into the person behind the counter.
“Carmine cares deeply about his craft and about feeding his community the best way he knows how,” wrote Chace in his review. “He cares that you'll love what he makes, like you're a guest in his home.”
Benttinen said he was so touched by the personal nature of Chace’s review that he immediately reached out to see if he’d be interested in being filmed for a documentary. Chace agreed, and soon he and Benttinen were traveling around the state together.
It wasn’t all fun and games, though. Chace’s goal of visiting 40 pizzerias in a month was derailed by an illness and a broken ankle. Even more challenging was an obstacle Chace had to confront to write his detailed, often humorous reviews.
“I was someone who grew up and has always, despite the jobs that I’ve had, had to deal with issues with social anxiety,” said Chace. “Now I’m forced, in order to do a good job with what I’m doing for people and for myself, I have to come out of that shell. It was a pretty emotional kind of moment, how much I’ve changed as a result.”
While the documentary focuses on Chace’s journey from educator to viral pizza reviewer, Benttinen says the film also uses pizzerias as a vehicle to showcase the people and personalities that shape Rhode Island. To do that, he introduces the viewer to a pizza joint that’s off the beaten path, to say the least: Lucky’s Bar and Pizza in Foster.
“When I started filming there, I knew they had to be a bigger part of the story because everyone I met there was just so wonderful and so incredible,” said Chace. “As Tim really taught me, pizzerias matter. They have this power to bring people together and to punctuate important times in one’s life, whether it’s winning your high school football championship or whatever it is.”
As an independent filmmaker, Benttinen has a broader goal of encouraging more people to come out to the theater. He says “The Pizza Principal” is a model for what he’s looking to do: shine a spotlight on ordinary people with big dreams, two things that Rhode Islanders can relate to.
In that sense, Benttinen is confident that Tim Chace’s pursuit of his childhood passion will resonate with viewers.
“I do believe that most of us are carrying something inside us where we think, ‘You know, if I could do anything, it would be this,’” said Benttinen. “I hope by sharing Tim’s story and the courage he had to pursue this, (it) affects everyone in that room and that they leave feeling that they could take a crack at something meaningful to them.”
“The Pizza Principal” premieres at 8:00 p.m. Friday at the Uptown Theater in Providence. A Q&A with Chace, Benttinen, and local pizzamakers will immediately follow the film, along with - you guessed it - a pizza party.