About 800 unionized workers at Butler Hospital, on Providence's East Side, went on strike on May 15, 2025.
About 800 unionized workers at Butler Hospital, on Providence’s East Side, went on strike on May 15, 2025.
Lynn Arditi

In Epilogue to Butler Hospital Strike, City Drops Picket Line Fines

Share
About 800 unionized workers at Butler Hospital, on Providence's East Side, went on strike on May 15, 2025.
About 800 unionized workers at Butler Hospital, on Providence’s East Side, went on strike on May 15, 2025.
Lynn Arditi
In Epilogue to Butler Hospital Strike, City Drops Picket Line Fines
Copy

The city of Providence reversed course on a half-dozen noise violations issued to striking Butler Hospital workers earlier this year, each carrying a $500 fine.

The backpedal comes three days after striking Butler Hospital workers voted to approve a new labor agreement that concluded their three-month-long walkout. Approximately 720 members of SEIU 1199NE work at the Providence psychiatric hospital.

The six violations were issued early in the strike, during late May and early June. All six violations involved what the city’s municipal code calls “excessive” or “amplified” noise from bullhorns or vehicle horns on the picket line on Blackstone Boulevard.

Josh Estrella, a spokesperson for Providence Mayor Brett Smiley, said via email Thursday that the city made “an administrative decision” not to pursue further action on the matter and has dropped the fines.

“As with all municipal court cases, the Solicitor’s office reviews the matter and evaluates whether or not to prosecute,” Estrella wrote. “This is done on a case-by-case basis.”

The Providence City Council took partial credit for the reversal in a Thursday morning press release, citing “sustained pressure from Council leadership” as an impetus for the fines’ negation.

“Earlier this week, we celebrated the ratification of a contract that meaningfully improves their lives,” Council President Rachel Miller said in a statement. “Today, we welcome the reversal of unjust noise citations that should never have been issued.”

“$500 fines could not quiet the striking workers, whose tenacity and solidarity led directly to a strong new contract,” Miller continued. “When the City punished workers for raising their voices, we raised ours, and I’m happy today to see the penalties dropped.”

Over the course of the strike, several councilors, including Miller, marched the picket line alongside workers. The City Council also passed a resolution on June 5 in support of the workers.

An update posted Thursday to Butler’s negotiations website, ButlerInfoForYou.org, noted that back-to-work instructions were sent to union workers on Tuesday via certified mail.

SEIU 1199NE did not immediately respond to a request for comment Thursday.

This story was originally published by the Rhode Island Current.

As we head into a new year, the Possibly team decided to think about all of our episodes, and how they might inspire our resolutions for 2026. Here’s what some of us had to say
Thousands of Rhode Islanders insured by HealthSourceRI face steep premium increases expected to take effect in 2026
A few weeks ago, Rhode Island lost beloved musician and teacher Rory MacLeod. As we close out 2025, we’re sharing some excerpts from a studio session earlier this year with Rory and his wife, fiddle player Sandol Astrausky
Rhode Island’s senators say the Trump Justice Department bypassed a bipartisan process in appointing Charles ‘Chas’ Calenda, calling him unqualified for the top federal prosecutor role
‘I don’t have an additional $900 lying around in my family budget to pay for this’
Research from Salve Regina University shows many libraries across southern New England are dealing with employee burnout and high rates of turnover as they try to adapt to modern-day patron needs