Smiley says response was strong, still orders independent review of Brown shooting

Mayor Brett Smiley said initial indications are positive, but that he ordered the city to engage an outside firm to review the city’s response

Mayor Brett Smiley gives media briefing on the ongoing Brown University investigation.
Mayor Brett Smiley giving media briefing the night of the Brown University investigation.
Ian Donnis/ Ocean State Media
Share
Mayor Brett Smiley gives media briefing on the ongoing Brown University investigation.
Mayor Brett Smiley giving media briefing the night of the Brown University investigation.
Ian Donnis/ Ocean State Media
Smiley says response was strong, still orders independent review of Brown shooting
Copy

The City of Providence is hiring an independent consulting firm to review the city’s response to the Brown University shooting.

Mayor Brett Smiley said the purpose of the review, which he said will likely take months to complete, is to ensure the city learns important lessons that can be applied to future emergencies.

“I look forward to the full and complete report, which will be shared with the community when that’s done,” Smiley told Ocean State Media’s Ian Donnis. “That’s going to be in-depth.”

In the aftermath of the deadly shooting at Brown University, Providence Mayor Brett Smiley reflected on what the city did right following the tragedy and what it can do better in the event of future emergencies

After an initial study, Smiley said he’s satisfied with the way Providence police and fire personnel responded to the shooting.

“The (response) within that first hour was excellent,” Smiley said. “You couldn’t do better.”

In a letter sent Tuesday to the Providence Emergency Management Agency, Smiley included a timeline of the city’s initial response to the shooting. The emergency dispatch center sent out police and fire resources “approximately 1 minute 22 seconds after (it received the) first call,” according to the timeline. Police were on the scene roughly 4 minutes later.

All 11 victims of the shooting were on their way to Rhode Island Hospital within 18 minutes, according to the timeline.

Smiley said the city will determine whether there is a more effective way to notify community members following a major incident. He has been criticized in recent weeks for choosing not to send out cell phone alerts, like those pushed to phones for an Amber Alert in a suspected child abduction case, following the Brown shooting.

Smiley said those alerts can give away one’s hiding place in an active shooting situation.

“Is there something in between that might better notify the community but that doesn’t endanger anybody?” Smiley asked. “That’s what we’re exploring right now and exploring what other options might be available to us.”

From lunar missions and eclipses to supermoons, auroras and a fading interstellar comet, 2026 promises a busy year in the skies
Bryant, URI and Johnson & Wales reached new heights, the Patriots stunned the NFL, and high school dynasties rolled on in a year full of highs — and hard lessons
Dr. Rasha Alawieh was deported to her native Lebanon in March
As we head into a new year, the Possibly team decided to think about all of our episodes, and how they might inspire our resolutions for 2026. Here’s what some of us had to say
Thousands of Rhode Islanders insured by HealthSourceRI face steep premium increases expected to take effect in 2026
A few weeks ago, Rhode Island lost beloved musician and teacher Rory MacLeod. As we close out 2025, we’re sharing some excerpts from a studio session earlier this year with Rory and his wife, fiddle player Sandol Astrausky