City Council sues New Bedford’s mayor over police chief appointment

Council leaders argue the mayor violated the city charter by naming John Thody as police chief without council approval, asking a judge to clarify their authority to confirm department heads

Council president Shane Burgo said that not allowing the council to confirm the appointee subverted its authority to confirm the appointment of department heads.
Council president Shane Burgo said that not allowing the council to confirm the appointee subverted its authority to confirm the appointment of department heads.
Paul C. Kelly Campos/The Public’s Radio
Share
Council president Shane Burgo said that not allowing the council to confirm the appointee subverted its authority to confirm the appointment of department heads.
Council president Shane Burgo said that not allowing the council to confirm the appointee subverted its authority to confirm the appointment of department heads.
Paul C. Kelly Campos/The Public’s Radio
City Council sues New Bedford’s mayor over police chief appointment
Copy

The New Bedford City Council filed a lawsuit against Mayor John Mitchell on Tuesday, asking a Bristol County Superior Court judge to clarify that the mayor must seek council approval to appoint a new police chief.

Mitchell appointed John Thody as the city’s new police chief on June 24.

Council president Shane Burgo said that not allowing the council to confirm the appointee subverted its authority to confirm the appointment of department heads.

“That is why we’re seeking a declaratory judgment from the courts to interpret our city code and our city charter and the Massachusetts General law that dictates under the Plan B charter that the council has this confirmation authority,” Burgo said.

The Mayor’s office contended in a press release that the council could schedule a confirmation vote but has not yet done so, stating that “the Council points to no provision in the Code that prevents it from casting this vote.”

A spokesman for Mitchell did not respond to an interview request.

Burgos said that unlike typical lawsuits, the end goal of this suit is not punitive, but rather to clarify the law in this instance.

“You’re not recognizing our confirmation authority and therein lies the conflict,” Burgos said.

The court has yet to set a timeline for the suit.

Mayor Brett Smiley discusses how his administration is tackling the city’s biggest issues — from the housing shortage and SNAP crisis to community trust in police — as he looks ahead to a 2026 re-election bid
USDA says it will not send out food stamp money in November due to the federal shutdown. Now, Rhode Islanders are grappling with how to make ends meet
Federal cuts to Medicaid could leave up to 50,000 Rhode Islanders without health insurance, straining the state’s already limited primary care system and putting communities like Central Falls - where half the population relies on Medicaid - at particular risk, according to Dr. Michael Fine
Gov. Dan McKee says the state will shift $6 million from other federal programs to help feed Rhode Islanders as SNAP benefits run out — while Attorney General Peter Neronha joins a multistate lawsuit against the Trump administration to restore funding
The R/V Endeavor, which spent the last 49 years operating out of URI’s Narragansett Bay Campus, was retired last month. Possibly took a tour of the vessel before it’s decommissioned